|
What's the difference between
hypertonic and isotonic sports drinks? Which one
is better?
Tonicity is a measure of osmotic
pressure, or in very non science terms, it tells us how much solid
type stuff (solutes) are in a liquid. Hypertonic
means there is a greater tonicity than the control subject,
isotonic tells us its equal to the control and hypotonic means
there is less than tonicity or osmotic pressure than the
control.
The ‘control' is whatever we're
comparing tonicity. For example, blood has an
osmotic pressure of 7.65atm at 37.5degrees, so anything the same as
this is isotonic.
And this is where sports drinks come
in.
•·
Isotonic sports drinks provide around 6%-8% CHO and sodium
(typically). This makes it the closest "formula"
to your blood and is thought to provide the most rapid
absorption. But note, if you eat a CHO or gel or
even drink water along with your Isotonic sports drink the entire
ingestion will be either hypertonic or
hypotonic. So when practicing your sports
nutrition, try just having your isotonic sports drink on its own to
see if the rapid absorption produces better results for you.
•·
Hypotonic sports drinks provide less than 6%-8% CHO and
sodium, so is a little better for those wanting a lower sugar hit
or who may already be taking an electrolyte
supplement. Some athletes perform better on a
hypotonic solution than an isotonic, so have a play around with the
different tonicities and see what feels better for
you. Wapnir & Lifshitz
suggest, with good evidence that hypotonic solutions provide the
most rapid hydration.
•·
Hypertonic sports drinks provide greater than 8% of CHO and
sodium, and is greater than the ratio your blood is
carrying. This ratio makes the fluids from the
drink slower to absorb, but good for long term replenishment of
carbs and sodium. If you need a quick hit of
carb or sodium, isotonic may be the better
choice for you. But again, each athlete is
different. If you are quite dehydrated the rate
of absorption of a Hypertonic sports drink may not be fast enough
for you and make your dehydration more severe.
If you're
trying to lose weight or just doing your daily hour at the gym you
don't need a sports drink. And if you've got a
good balanced diet, even a 2 hour gym session doesn't require a
sports drink.
In a nutshell,
it basically means how much sugar and sodium is in your
water. Each athlete is different, and different
conditions may require a different formulation.
For example you may do well on a hypertonic drink doing a marathon
in winter, but an ultra-marathon in summer can dehydrate you
quickly, so an iso or hypo tonic solution may be best for rapid
fluid absorption.
Whatever you decide to use, keep rule
number one firmly in mind:
If you haven't practiced it
first....don't do it on the day.
|